In the 1950s, a suburban Chicago housewife named Dorothy Martin headed a small doomsday cult. One of the first of its kind! Dorothy believed she had a direct line to an alien. Sananda, a celestial guide from Clairion. With no formal platform or technology to spread her revelations, Dorothy turned to a surprisingly ordinary method—hosting informal gatherings where her friends could ask Sananda questions, sandwiched between Tupperware sales and alien shaped cupcakes (seriously). But these conversations weren’t about household hacks—they were warnings of an impending apocalypse, and only the worthy would be spared.

Psychologist Leon Festinger saw an opportunity to study belief under pressure, sending students to infiltrate The Seekers. As the predicted doomsday came and went without so much as a flicker from the skies, the group’s faith was put to the ultimate test. Their reactions—rationalizations, denials, and quiet departures—became the foundation for what we now call Cognitive Dissonance.

Throughout the episode, we explore the dynamics within The Seekers, the unwavering support of Dorothy’s husband, Harold, and the far more dubious influence of Charles Laughead. Ultimately, most followers simply returned to their everyday lives. But what happened to Dorothy and Charles? And how does belief endure when faced with undeniable contradiction? How does this apply in 2025?

Resources & Further Reading:

• The Seekers: UFO Doomsday Cult & Christmas Carols – The Sun

• The Seekers of Cuyler Avenue – Oak Park River Forest Museum

• Cognitive Dissonance & The Seekers – YouTube Documentary

• Lore Podcast – Aaron Mahnke’s Lore Podcast (for additional eerie cult stories)

Follow us on social media to stay up to date on what’s coming up!

🎧 Spotify: Listen Here
📺 YouTube: Watch & Subscribe
🌙 Facebook: Join Us
📸 Instagram: Follow Us
🔮 Patreon: Support Hex Haven

· Music Credit: Geoff Hardy - Let the Mystery Unfold via. Pixaby