Week 3 of the Karen Read retrial brought a dramatic shift from car crash theory to accusations of a violent breakup turned deadly. In this episode of Dead Diary, we break down every major moment: text messages, forensic evidence, emotional testimony, and the digital breadcrumbs that the Commonwealth claims hold the key to what happened the night John O’Keefe died.

You'll hear how the prosecution introduced a new expert witness, built a timeline down to the second, and doubled down on its narrative of rage and rejection. But the defense wasn’t backing down - raising questions about credentials, omissions at the crime scene, and whether the science actually matches the story.

If you’re following this case closely, this is an episode you don’t want to miss.

Subscribe for new weekly episodes.

Dead Diary is a production of Murder Creek Media, a woman-owned podcasting and media company. Without backing from any production studio or corporate entity, we have the freedom to explore cases thoroughly and tell the stories that matter the most. While this independence allows for creative control, it also means that we rely heavily on listener support to keep the show going. Please visit murdercreekmedia.com to learn more about us, our mission, and how you can support the show.

This episode was created with Descript, a podcast editing and transcription tool that’s been a game-changer for our production process. By signing up using our link, you’ll not only get a great tool but also help support our show.

Week two of the Karen Read retrial brought a wave of emotional testimony, conflicting timelines, and serious questions about the integrity of the investigation. From Jennifer McCabe’s shaky memory and a suspicious Google search to angry voicemails, flirtatious texts, and taillight fragments found after the snow melted, this case only gets more complicated. And when the lead investigator turns out to be a disgraced trooper with ties to the victim’s inner circle, it’s no wonder the jury - and the public - are still very much on edge.

Subscribe for new weekly episodes.

Dead Diary is a production of Murder Creek Media, a woman-owned podcasting and media company. Without backing from any production studio or corporate entity, we have the freedom to explore cases thoroughly and tell the stories that matter the most. While this independence allows for creative control, it also means that we rely heavily on listener support to keep the show going. Please visit murdercreekmedia.com to learn more about us, our mission, and how you can support the show.

This episode was created with Descript, a podcast editing and transcription tool that’s been a game-changer for our production process. By signing up using our link, you’ll not only get a great tool but also help support our show.

The death of Boston police officer John O'Keefe shocked the town of Canton - and when his girlfriend, Karen Read, was arrested for his murder, the fallout ignited national headlines. In this episode of Dead Diary, host Neeli Faulkner walks through the chilling timeline, the charges, and the two very different narratives at the center of the Karen Read retrial.

Was this a case of drunk driving and domestic violence? Or was Karen Read framed to protect someone from deep ties to law enforcement?

We break down the background, key players, first week of trial testimony, and the growing "Free Karen Read" movement that claims the real story has been buried beneath the lies, bias, and misconduct. From crime scene mishandling to digital forensic red flags, this trial is anything but simple.

If you're looking for a summary of one of the most controversial true crime cases in America right now, this is where to start.

Subscribe for new weekly episodes.

Dead Diary is a production of Murder Creek Media, a woman-owned podcasting and media company. Without backing from any production studio or corporate entity, we have the freedom to explore cases thoroughly and tell the stories that matter the most. While this independence allows for creative control, it also means that we rely heavily on listener support to keep the show going. Please visit murdercreekmedia.com to learn more about us, our mission, and how you can support the show.

This episode was created with Descript, a podcast editing and transcription tool that’s been a game-changer for our production process. By signing up using our link, you’ll not only get a great tool but also help support our show.